COMPARO: Sub-P1M A/T SUV or Crossover - Kia Soul CRDi, Grand Vitara, what else?

[jut703]

The GV is bigger than the Ecosport and ASX. But it's really really old. A lot of people in the office are getting it because of the low sticker price, but an old 4AT with a 2.4 engine gets really bad mileage.

The exterior looks timeless - it's the last of the boxy SUVs from the mid 2000's. However, the interior isn't my type, plus it doesn't have any of the modern amenities of newer cars.

Have not driven it, but they say that performance is forgettable even with the big engine, and handling is truck-like. It's not a crossover after all.

If you can stretch for the ASX, that's a better option. Or perhaps a gas Sportage if they give big discounts too.

[zerglingboy]

The GV is bigger than the Ecosport and ASX. But it's really really old. A lot of people in the office are getting it because of the low sticker price, but an old 4AT with a 2.4 engine gets really bad mileage.

The exterior looks timeless - it's the last of the boxy SUVs from the mid 2000's. However, the interior isn't my type, plus it doesn't have any of the modern amenities of newer cars.

Have not driven it, but they say that performance is forgettable even with the big engine, and handling is truck-like. It's not a crossover after all.

If you can stretch for the ASX, that's a better option. Or perhaps a gas Sportage if they give big discounts too.

hi sir nabanggit na lang din natin ung asx. which is at least 1.098M.

im torn between asx and soul. kung ikumpara ko yung soul ex sa gls ng asx panis na panis sa interior gadgets ang soul.
ung soul lx kasi parang sobrang bare kahit ung mags kasi di maganda. papalitin.
nalilito n ako ngayun.

kagagaling ko lang sa mitsu alabang to check naman ung asx.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The GV is bigger than the Ecosport and ASX. But it's really really old. A lot of people in the office are getting it because of the low sticker price, but an old 4AT with a 2.4 engine gets really bad mileage.

The exterior looks timeless - it's the last of the boxy SUVs from the mid 2000's. However, the interior isn't my type, plus it doesn't have any of the modern amenities of newer cars.

Have not driven it, but they say that performance is forgettable even with the big engine, and handling is truck-like. It's not a crossover after all.

If you can stretch for the ASX, that's a better option. Or perhaps a gas Sportage if they give big discounts too.

hi sir nabanggit na lang din natin ung asx. which is at least 1.098M.

im torn between asx and soul. kung ikumpara ko yung soul ex sa gls ng asx panis na panis sa interior gadgets ang soul.
ung soul lx kasi parang sobrang bare kahit ung mags kasi di maganda. papalitin.
nalilito n ako ngayun.

kagagaling ko lang sa mitsu alabang to check naman ung asx.

[ano727]

The GV is bigger than the Ecosport and ASX. But it's really really old. A lot of people in the office are getting it because of the low sticker price, but an old 4AT with a 2.4 engine gets really bad mileage.

The exterior looks timeless - it's the last of the boxy SUVs from the mid 2000's. However, the interior isn't my type, plus it doesn't have any of the modern amenities of newer cars.

Have not driven it, but they say that performance is forgettable even with the big engine, and handling is truck-like. It's not a crossover after all.

If you can stretch for the ASX, that's a better option. Or perhaps a gas Sportage if they give big discounts too.

What about the EcoSport? It's within budget, but I hear some quality issues from the other thread.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The GV is bigger than the Ecosport and ASX. But it's really really old. A lot of people in the office are getting it because of the low sticker price, but an old 4AT with a 2.4 engine gets really bad mileage.

The exterior looks timeless - it's the last of the boxy SUVs from the mid 2000's. However, the interior isn't my type, plus it doesn't have any of the modern amenities of newer cars.

Have not driven it, but they say that performance is forgettable even with the big engine, and handling is truck-like. It's not a crossover after all.

If you can stretch for the ASX, that's a better option. Or perhaps a gas Sportage if they give big discounts too.

What about the EcoSport? It's within budget, but I hear some quality issues from the other thread.

[jut703]

What about the EcoSport? It's within budget, but I hear some quality issues from the other thread.

Too cramped. Plus the DCT is still a big question mark. About 10-20% of Fiesta owners have DCT issues, usually ending up with the PCM/TCM having to be replaced, which is a 60k expense once warranty expires.

If you're getting an Ecosport, get the Trend MT. Otherwise, just up your budget for an ASX, Tucson, Sportage, or Vitara.

[jut703]

ASX over Soul definitely. Di ko trip itsura ng Soul. Not very spacious either. Plus resale value will also be a disadvantage vs the ASX.

CRDi lang lamang ng Soul.